Why do AI assistants quote “best in town” lists so often?

AI assistants quote “best of” lists because a good list does their job for them: it compares several options on one page and gives reasons for each. Ahrefs analysed 26,283 source URLs behind ChatGPT’s answers to 750 recommendation prompts (December 2025) and found “best X” lists made up 43.8% of all the pages cited, more than any other type of page.

Other research points the same way. Evertune, a company that sells AI visibility tracking, reported in a sponsored Search Engine Land article (May 2026) that 63% of nearly 400 million citations across six AI platforms pointed to list-style pages, typically 1,000 to 2,000 words with clear headings. And in Whitespark’s 2026 Local Search Ranking Factors survey, 47 local search experts rated being on expert-curated “best of” lists as the single most important factor for AI search visibility.

Ahrefs studied software, products and agencies rather than local services, but the local equivalents are easy to spot: local newspaper roundups, “top 10” posts on community blogs and directory category pages.

Does my position on the list matter?

Yes: businesses near the top of a list get recommended more often. Ahrefs split each cited list into thirds and found “a strong trend” towards the businesses ranked higher. On average, 45% of the brands ChatGPT recommended sat in the top third of a list, against 24% in the bottom third. When you pitch, aim for a fair place in the top third, backed by evidence.

Do the lists need to be recent?

Yes. Recently updated lists are the ones AI assistants tend to quote. Of 1,100 cited lists Ahrefs checked, 79.1% had last been updated in 2025, the year of the study, and 26% in the previous two months. A roundup last touched in 2019 is far less likely to be used, so check the dates and ask authors whether they plan a refresh.

How do I find the “best in town” lists for my business?

Search Google and Bing for the phrases your customers would type, and write down every list that appears. Check Bing as well as Google, because some assistants, Microsoft Copilot among them, search Bing rather than Google; our guide to which AI uses which search engine explains the differences.

  1. Run the searchesTry “best [service] in [town]”, “top [service] [town]” and “[service] [town] recommendations”, then repeat with your county and nearby towns.
  2. Ask the AI assistants tooPut the same questions to ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity and note which pages they cite. Our free AI prompt checker builds the prompts for you, with one-click links.
  3. Log every listRecord the web address, outlet, author, date last updated, who is listed, where you appear (if at all) and how to contact the author.
  4. PrioritiseStart with recently updated lists on established local sites, especially any the AI assistants already cite.

How do I pitch a list author?

Send a short, polite email with a ready-made proof pack that makes including you easy. Writers want accurate, useful recommendations, so your job is to show you belong on the list, not to demand the top spot. A good proof pack includes:

  • Your rating and number of reviews on Google and your main review platform, with links.
  • Accreditations, registrations and insurance.
  • Two or three good photos, with permission to use them.
  • One or two concrete facts: years trading, specialisms, notable local work, evening opening.
  • Your standard two-to-three-sentence description and correct contact details.

Never offer payment or gifts for a place on a list that presents itself as independent. If an outlet sells sponsored places, they should be clearly labelled as advertising.

What should the pitch email say?

A good pitch is under 150 words, personal and specific. Here’s an example for a made-up clinic, with gaps for your own details:

Subject: A suggestion for your best skin clinics in Reigate guide

Hi [first name],

I enjoyed your guide to the best skin clinics in Reigate, and wondered whether you might consider Bramblewick Skin Clinic when you next update it.

We’re a nurse-led clinic on Reigate High Street, open since [year]. We’re rated [rating] from [number] Google reviews, we’re fully insured, and we offer free consultations and Thursday evening appointments.

I’ve attached three photos you’re welcome to use, plus our details. I’m happy to answer any questions if that helps.

Thanks for putting the guide together either way. It’s genuinely useful for people locally.

Best wishes,
[your name]
Bramblewick Skin Clinic
[phone] · [website]

What if there’s no “best of” list for my town?

Pitch the idea to your local paper, a community magazine or a respected local blogger. Local outlets need content, and a well-sourced roundup such as “the most recommended [service] in [town], by review score” is easy for them to write. Suggest the criteria rather than the winner, name fair alternatives and offer your proof pack. Even if the piece lists you fifth, a mention on an established local site is exactly the kind of independent signal AI assistants look for, as we explain in why reviews and mentions matter more than your own website.

Should I publish my own “best [service] in [town]” page?

Publish one honest comparison or cost page if you like, but avoid a self-ranked list that names you number one. Self-promotional lists can get cited: when a software company was among those recommended, its own “best” list appeared in more than a third of ChatGPT responses in Ahrefs’ study, though the share was far lower for agencies (17.2%) and products (4%). They have also become risky. Seer Interactive found ChatGPT’s citations of “best” and “top” pages fell 30% from December 2025 to January 2026 (published February 2026), and since May 2026 Google’s spam policies explicitly cover “attempting to manipulate generative AI responses”.

In February 2026, SEO researcher Lily Ray published an analysis of seven software brands that lost roughly 29–49% of their US Google visibility (measured by Sistrix) from mid-January, many of which had published dozens or hundreds of self-promotional “best” articles. Google hasn’t confirmed a specific update, and some SEOs dispute the cause, but it isn’t a risk worth taking with the website your customers use.

The safer version is a genuinely useful page, such as “How much does [service] cost in [town]? Our prices and what affects them” or “How to choose a [service] in [town]: the questions to ask”. Use real prices, honest comparisons and named sources.

Why is mass-producing “best X in every town” pages risky?

Mass-produced town pages are risky because Google’s spam policies describe that pattern almost word for word. Scaled content abuse is when “many pages are generated for the primary purpose of manipulating search rankings and not helping users”, and Google’s examples of doorway abuse include “having multiple domain names or pages targeted at specific regions or cities that funnel users to one page”. The same policies count “attempting to manipulate generative AI responses in Google Search” as spam, and Google says sites that break them “may rank lower in results or not appear in results at all”.

One genuinely local page for each area you really serve, with real detail such as recent jobs, travel times and local landmarks, is fine. Fifty near-identical copies with the town name swapped are not.

How do I keep list placements working?

Check every list you’re on once a year. Ask authors to update your details when anything changes, send fresh proof when your rating improves, and look for new lists each quarter. Because AI assistants favour recently updated lists, a placement on a list that’s never refreshed will gradually count for less.

Frequently asked questions

Do directory category pages count as “best of” lists?

They work in a similar way. A directory page listing the businesses for a service in your town is a ready-made comparison for an AI assistant, which is one more reason to keep your directory profiles complete and well reviewed.

What if a list has the wrong details about my business?

Email the author with your correct name, address, phone number and description. Inconsistent details make it harder for AI assistants to match the mention to your business.

Will being on a list guarantee that ChatGPT recommends me?

No. AI answers change from one run to the next: in SparkToro’s 2026 test, the same prompt returned the same list of brands less than 1 time in 100. Lists improve your odds, so measure how often you’re mentioned over time using our step-by-step method.

Is it worth getting onto national lists as well as local ones?

For most local businesses, local lists matter more, because people ask AI assistants for a service in a particular town. National lists are worth pursuing if you serve customers across the UK.

Sources